Grinders
Blade vs burr coffee grinder: which fits your brewer?
Blade, burr or pre-ground: what Fellow and Baratza say about each grinder type, and how five brewer makers' grind lines decide which one you need.
Assessment based on manufacturer documentation and independent published sources; we have not physically tested these products.
By Syed Hyder Ali · Updated · How we research
In short
Choose a burr grinder over a blade grinder if you want to repeat the same grind. A blade grinder chops, so its grind size "depends entirely on duration" and comes out as "a mix of fine powder and larger chunks of coffee" (Fellow); a burr grinder crushes beans between two burrs and gives you a numbered setting to return to.
Some grinder makers print a chart, such as OXO's "Medium / 6-10". If it uses the same word your brewer's manual does, the chart tells you where to set the dial.
Whether you need a grinder at all depends on your brewer. We cover AeroPress, Moccamaster, Bonavita, OXO and Chemex. A grinder is optional with AeroPress and Bonavita, whose makers allow for pre-ground coffee. Moccamaster says most bagged pre-ground is too fine, so grind your own unless the pack says medium to medium-coarse. OXO and Chemex don't mention pre-ground, so buy it only if the pack's grind matches the word they ask for. If your brewer isn't listed, compare its manual's grind line with the grinder maker's chart, as in the worked example.
Worked example
- Brewer
- OXO Brew 8-Cup Coffee Maker (8718800)
- OXO's 8-Cup manual asks for
- "approximately 8 grams of medium-ground coffee per cup (5 fl oz)"
- Grinder
- OXO Brew Conical Burr Coffee Grinder (8717000), 15 settings
- Grinder maker's chart, entry for "Pour Over/Drip Coffee"
- "Medium / 6-10" (OXO 8717000 manual)
Take the grind word your brewer's maker uses ("medium"). Find the same word in your grinder maker's chart. The chart gives the settings. For the dose, multiply grams per cup by cups: 8 g x 8 cups = 64 g of coffee.
Settings 6-10 of 15, and 64 g of coffee for a full pot
This only works when the chart has your brewer's word. OXO's chart gives a fineness word and a setting range for each brew method; its words are Fine (1-5), Medium (6-10) and Coarse (11-15). Phrases that combine words, such as Moccamaster's "medium to medium-coarse", Bonavita's "medium / course", Chemex's "medium coarse" and AeroPress's "Medium Fine", are not one of those words, so no single setting range follows for those brewers. OXO doesn't say its brewer and grinder go together; we matched the word "medium" ourselves.
Assumptions and exclusions
This assumes
- Home filter brewing.
- Whole beans.
- The four electric burr grinders in the settings table.
This does not cover
- Espresso grinding.
- Recipes and grind charts.
- Hand-grinder buying.
- Prices: we don't cover price here.
What is the difference between a blade and a burr grinder?
The practical difference is whether you can return to the same grind. A blade grinder chops: Fellow states that it uses "a spinning metal propeller to chop coffee beans" and that "Rather than using an engineered, adjustable setting, the final grind size depends entirely on duration". It adds: "Blades often grind your coffee unevenly, resulting in a mix of fine powder and larger chunks of coffee." Coffee Chronicler reports, in Burr Grinder vs Blade Grinder: Which One Should You Get? (November 23, 2021), "It’s simply impossible to get the same result with the blade grinder each time you use it." With a blade there is no setting to write down and go back to.
A burr grinder crushes beans between two burrs. Fellow states that it "utilizes two burrs, one fixed and one rotary, to crush beans to a uniform size". Two shapes exist: "Conical burr grinders feature a cone-shaped inner burr resting within a ring-shaped outer burr", and flat burr grinders "utilize two parallel rings with serrated edges" (Fellow). Baratza states of its conical burrs that "the distance between the cone burr and the outer ring burr define a maximum grind size". Because that gap, not a timer, limits the size, a numbered scale gives you a setting to return to.
Fellow and Baratza both sell burr grinders, so read their comparisons with that in mind. Coffee Chronicler, an independent review site, agrees about the blade grinder's repeatability.
Which numbered scale does each burr grinder give you?
This table is not a ranking, and this page picks no grinder (the pour-over grinder guide linked below does). A settings count is each maker's own scale, so 40 settings on the Encore and 11 on the Ode (Fellow lists the Ode as 11 settings with 31 total steps) do not rank the grinders. A setting number only means something on its own grinder, so don't copy a setting from another grinder's recipe: setting 12 sits in the lower third of the Encore's 40 (12 ÷ 40 = 0.3) but in the "Coarse" range (11-15) of OXO's 15-setting chart.
| Grinder | Grind settings |
|---|---|
40 settings, "from very coarse (grind setting 40) to very fine (grind setting 1)" | |
Baratza Encore ESP Coffee Grinder (ZCG495) | 40 settings; "the espresso range (settings 1-20)" and "the filter coffee range (settings 21-40)" |
11 settings with 31 total steps | |
OXO Brew Conical Burr Coffee Grinder (8717000) | 15 grind size settings (1 = fine, 15 = coarse), plus additional microsettings |
What grind does your brewer's maker ask for?
Find your brewer in the table and take its maker's own word for the grind; that word is what you match against a grinder's chart. Not decided on a brewer yet? Start with pour-over vs drip. Once you have the grind, the amount of coffee per cup is a ratio question: see the coffee-to-water ratio guide.
| Brewer | Grind the maker asks for | Mentions pre-ground coffee? |
|---|---|---|
AeroPress Original (85A01) | Leaflet, grinder instructions: "Coffee Grind Size: Medium Fine" | Yes, in the leaflet's instructions without a grinder: "Pre‑Ground Coffee", "Coffee Grind Size: Medium" |
Moccamaster KBT and KBGV Select | Manual (covers all its US brewers): "Use a medium to medium-coarse grind." | Yes, as a caution: "Note that most pre-ground, bagged coffee tends to be too finely ground for ideal operation." |
Bonavita Connoisseur 8-Cup (BV1901TS) | Manual: "medium / course setting, similar to course ground salt" (the manual's spelling) | Yes: "Whether you are purchasing pre-ground coffee or grinding it just before you brew, we recommend using coffee that is ground to a medium / course setting"; also "While we encourage grinding your coffee immediately before brewing whenever possible, we know that there are times when pre-grinding can’t be avoided." |
OXO Brew 8-Cup Coffee Maker (8718800) | Manual: "approximately 8 grams of medium-ground coffee per cup (5 fl oz)"; troubleshooting: "Try using a medium grind; too fine a grind may cause water build-up." | Doesn't mention pre-ground coffee |
Chemex Six Cup Classic; the support page covers the Three, Six, Eight and Ten Cup Classic | Support page: "Grind your favorite whole bean coffee to a medium coarse ground." | Doesn't mention pre-ground coffee |
Is a burr grinder worth it for your brewer?
Our verdict by situation:
- You want to repeat a grind: buy a burr grinder. A blade grinder's result depends on duration and, per Coffee Chronicler, can't be matched from one run to the next; a numbered burr grinder gives a setting to return to. That holds for every brewer in the table.
- The grinder's chart has your brewer's word: a burr grinder plus the chart gives you the setting. OXO's chart lists "Medium / 6-10" for pour over and drip coffee and the OXO 8-Cup manual asks for medium, so the example lands on settings 6-10 of 15.
- The chart lacks your brewer's word: a burr grinder still repeats a grind, but you pick the setting. No chart gives it to you; our suggestion is to start at the chart's closest word.
- You already own a blade grinder: keep it only if you can live without a repeatable grind. Its size depends on how long you run it (Fellow), so you can steer a grind but not return to it. Switch to a burr grinder when you want the same result each time.
- Your brewer's maker allows pre-ground coffee: a grinder is a preference, not a requirement. The next section sorts the five makers.
Burr grinders aren't uniform by default: Tom's Guide reports one model, the Encore ESP, as less uniform and consistent than other grinders its reviewer has used. That is one review, not a rule.
For a model to buy, see the best grinders for pour-over.
Can you stay with pre-ground coffee?
- AeroPress and Bonavita: a grinder is optional. AeroPress's leaflet gives instructions without a grinder ("Pre‑Ground Coffee", "Medium") beside its grinder instructions ("Medium Fine"). Bonavita's manual recommends "a medium / course setting" whether you buy pre-ground coffee or grind just before brewing. What a grinder adds is a setting you choose and the option to grind just before brewing, which Bonavita says it encourages "whenever possible".
- Moccamaster: check the pack, or grind. Its manual says most bagged pre-ground coffee tends to be "too finely ground for ideal operation" and suggests grinding at the time of purchase or at home. If the pack doesn't say medium to medium-coarse, grind your own.
- OXO and Chemex: match the pack to the maker's word. Neither mentions pre-ground coffee, so we can't say whether the makers accept it. If you buy it for these brewers, the grind on the pack needs to be the one the maker asks for: medium for OXO, which also warns that too fine a grind may cause water build-up, and medium coarse for Chemex.
Capsule machines need no grinder, so a Nespresso machine skips this choice. If your brewer is not chosen yet, compare the best drip coffee makers and the best pour-over makers.
Models this page mentions
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page.
In the order the page mentions them; not a ranking.
Mentioned in: Which numbered scale does each burr grinder give you?

Baratza Encore Conical Burr Coffee Grinder

Baratza Encore ESP Coffee Grinder

Fellow Ode Brew Grinder Gen 2
- OXO Brew Conical Burr Coffee GrinderView on Amazon, OXO Brew Conical Burr Coffee Grinder (opens in a new tab)
Sources
- Burr Grinders vs. Blade Grinders: Understanding the Difference — Fellow, accessed November 16, 2026
- Conical & Flat Coffee Grinders: Shop by Burr — Baratza (Breville USA), accessed November 16, 2026
- Burr Grinder vs Blade Grinder: Which One Should You Get? — Coffee Chronicler, accessed November 16, 2026
- Baratza Encore ESP review — Tom's Guide, accessed November 16, 2026
- AeroPress Clear / Original instructions (English leaflet) — AeroPress, accessed November 16, 2026
- Moccamaster USA instruction manual v23.0 (all brewers) — Moccamaster USA, accessed November 16, 2026
- Connoisseur Performance Coffee Brewer 8-Cup BV1901TS manual (2021 edition) — Bonavita, accessed November 16, 2026
- OXO Brew 8-Cup Coffee Maker instruction manual (Brew_8718800 M03) — OXO, accessed November 16, 2026
- OXO Conical Burr Coffee Grinder instruction manual (OXO_Brew_8717000_Booklet) — OXO, accessed November 16, 2026
- OXO US product page, Conical Burr Coffee Grinder 8717000 (Internet Archive copy captured 2026-11-09) — OXO, accessed November 16, 2026
- Classic Series Info and Support — CHEMEX, accessed November 16, 2026
- Encore Operations Manual v4.3 (December 2022) — Baratza (Breville USA), accessed November 16, 2026
- Encore ESP Operations Manual v1.0 (January 2023) — Baratza (Breville USA), accessed November 16, 2026
- Ode Brew Grinder Gen 2 - US product page — Fellow, accessed November 16, 2026