Pour-over
Paper vs metal coffee filters: which one your brewer allows
Which filter your brewer's maker lists, what makers say each one lets through, and what three studies report about cafestol and kahweol, the coffee oils linked to cholesterol. A report of studies, not medical advice.
Assessment based on manufacturer documentation and independent published sources; we have not physically tested these products.
By Syed Hyder Ali · Updated · How we research
In short
Use paper unless your brewer's maker lists a reusable filter and you want the fuller body that makers of metal filters describe. Studies report that paper retains the coffee oils cafestol and kahweol; makers state that metal lets them through. Of the 28 brewers we cover, 3 makers list a reusable option (AeroPress Original, Breville Luxe Brewer Thermal, Ratio Six Series 2), 4 advise against one or will not guarantee it (Moccamaster KBGV Select, KBT and KBGT; Chemex Ottomatic 2.0), 1 does not say (OXO Brew 8-Cup) and 20 list paper only. If you are managing cholesterol, ask a clinician: this page reports studies and gives no advice.
Worked example
- Dripper and brewer models covered
- 28
- Makers list paper only, say nothing on reusable
- 20
- Makers advise against, or will not guarantee, one
- 4
- Maker's manual leaves a reusable filter unknown
- 1
28 − 20 − 4 − 1 = 3 brewers whose makers list a reusable option
3 of 28 brewers list a reusable filter
Models as read on 2026-11-16. Not listed means the maker's pages say nothing either way, not that a metal filter is refused.
Assumptions and exclusions
This assumes
- Models and maker pages as read on 2026-11-16 and 2026-11-17
- Your brewer's maker listing comes first
- Cafestol figures are mg per litre of brewed coffee
- Paper means paper unless a study says fabric
This does not cover
- Taste verdicts and grind advice of our own
- Ranking or picking metal filter products
- Medical advice
- Espresso machine recommendations
Paper vs metal coffee filter: which should you use?
Start from your brewer, then your cup. "Not listed" below means the maker's pages say nothing either way; it is not a ban.
| If you | Use | Why |
|---|---|---|
Own a Moccamaster (KBGV Select, KBT or KBGT) | Paper | The maker's manual: "We advise against using gold-mesh or other reusable filters, as they can cause inconsistent extraction times and are difficult to clean properly." A third-party maker disagrees; see the last section. |
Own an AeroPress Original and want a fuller-bodied cup | The metal disc, or paper | AeroPress states its stainless steel filter works with the Original and lets oils through for a somewhat fuller-bodied cup. Paper keeps them out, in AeroPress's words. |
Own a Breville Luxe Brewer Thermal | Paper, or the supplied mesh basket filter, never both | Breville's manual says paper gives "superior taste & clarity" and that the mesh lets some fine grounds into the cup as sediment. It also says never to use both together. |
Own a Ratio Six Series 2 | Paper or the Able Basket | Ratio's site sells the Able Basket stainless filter for the Six and Eight Series 2. |
Own a V60, Chemex Classic, Kalita Wave or another of the 20 models whose maker lists paper only | Paper | Your maker names no metal option. A third-party maker may state that its filter fits; that is its claim, not your brewer's maker's. |
Want the oils kept out of the cup | Paper | Studies report that a paper filter retains cafestol and kahweol. None of the three read measured a metal cone or disc (see below). |
Are managing cholesterol | Ask your clinician | This page reports what studies say about coffee oils. It does not advise. |
If you stay on paper, the right size is a separate question: which paper fits which brewer, with a yearly filter-cost calculator. If your filter question is really a brewer question, choosing a manual dripper and choosing a drip machine cover it.
What does each filter let through, according to the makers?
These are makers' claims about their own products, not findings. None comes with a measurement except one hole size.
| Maker and filter | What it states |
|---|---|
AeroPress, stainless steel filter | It "allows oils to pass through for a somewhat fuller-bodied cup of coffee, whereas the paper micro-filter keeps out those oils for a smoother, grit-free flavor profile." |
AeroPress, metal disc (blog) | "A metal disc does not absorb oils or withhold fines." Its holes are 178 microns in diameter, so it holds back most grounds and the fines pass into the cup and add texture. |
Chemex, bonded paper | It removes "sediment, acidity, bad fats and bitterness"; the product page calls it "20-30% thicker paper than most of the competition." The pages read give no measurement for either claim. |
Breville, mesh basket filter and paper (Luxe manual) | "Coffee with superior taste & clarity will come from using a paper filter." The mesh "will allow some fine coffee grounds to brew into the coffee", which "will appear as sediment in the cup or carafe." |
Able, Kone (third-party metal filter) | It "brews a full-bodied cup of coffee, rich with oils and flavors normally trapped by paper filtration." |
Moccamaster, on reusable filters | Advises against gold-mesh and other reusable filters: "inconsistent extraction times" and "difficult to clean properly." |
What do studies report about the oils in coffee, and which filters keep them out?
Cafestol and kahweol are oils in coffee beans. Three sources are worth knowing, and each has limits.
- Urgert and Katan, Annual Review of Nutrition, 1997. This review of papers to December 1996 reports that the oils are extracted by hot water and retained by a paper filter. It explains why filtered coffee does not affect cholesterol, while Scandinavian boiled, cafetière and Turkish coffee do.
- Jee et al., American Journal of Epidemiology, 2001. A meta-analysis of 14 randomized trials reports that unfiltered, but not filtered, coffee raises total and LDL cholesterol.
- Orrje et al., Nutrition, Metabolism and Cardiovascular Diseases, 2025. Swedish researchers measured cafestol in coffee from 14 machines in four health care facilities and in home brews. They report that most coffees from the 11 workplace brewing machines, which they say pass a metal filter, hold more cafestol than paper-filtered coffee and less than unfiltered coffee.
| Brew | Cafestol | What the figure is |
|---|---|---|
Liquid-model workplace machines (no filter) | 8.3 (range 2.4-343.4) | Median of 3 machines. One outlier sample; without it the mean is 5.9 (2.4-11.7). |
Paper-filtered drip, home-made | 11.5 (range 4.2-23.8) | Mean of both paper types, 5 brews, 10 samples. Ordinary filters 6.1 (4.2-23.8); perforated "aroma" filters 15.8 (8.2-17.0). |
Boiled coffee through a polyester/acrylic sock | 28.0 | Mean of duplicate analyses, one brew. |
French press | 86.8 | Mean of duplicate analyses. |
Percolator | 91.2 | Mean of duplicate analyses. |
All 14 workplace machines | 174.0 (range 2.4-444.0) | Mean of two sampling occasions; the range covers all 28 samples. |
Workplace brewing machines (metal filter) | 175.7 (range 24.4-444.0) | Median of 11 machines. |
Boiled coffee, unfiltered | 939.2 | Mean of duplicate analyses, one brew. |
Espresso | 1,059.3 (range 35.6-2,446.7) | Median of 4 samples. |
Read the limits before the numbers. None of the three sources measured a metal-cone dripper, an AeroPress disc or a Chemex-style metal cone, so this page cannot say how those compare with paper. Orrje et al. name their own limits: a small sample, and no detail on the filters inside each machine. They write that their estimated effects on LDL cholesterol "should be cautiously interpreted", and that their French press result came out lower than earlier studies, in which it resembled boiled coffee. The table shows every row of their cafestol column, including espresso, which varied widely between their four samples and is outside what this page covers.
This page reports what studies say about coffee oils. It is not medical advice: if you are managing cholesterol, ask a clinician.
Which of your brewers will take a metal filter?
This is every dripper and brewer model we cover, grouped by what its maker's pages say.
| Maker lists | Models |
|---|---|
A reusable option (3) | AeroPress Original Coffee Maker: the Flow Control Filter Cap takes Standard paper or metal filters, and AeroPress states its Standard stainless steel filter works with the Original, not the XL. Breville the Luxe Brewer Thermal: flat-base paper or the supplied mesh basket filter, never both. Ratio Six Series 2: paper or the Able Basket. |
A caution against one (4) | Moccamaster KBGV Select, KBT and KBGT: advises against gold-mesh and other reusable filters. Chemex Ottomatic 2.0: "We cannot guarantee the successful use of the CHEMEX Ottomatic if it is used with any non CHEMEX products such as plastic, metal or cloth filters." |
Unknown (1) | OXO Brew 8-Cup: the manual says look for basket filters labeled 8-12 cup and does not say whether a metal or reusable basket filter fits. |
Paper only, nothing said about a reusable filter (20) | Hario V60 01 and 02 (plastic, ceramic, glass); Hario Switch 02; Kalita Wave 155, and 185 (glass, Mino, stainless); Kalita 102; Chemex Classic Three, Six and Eight Cup; Fellow Aiden; Bonavita Connoisseur 8-Cup and Enthusiast 8-Cup Thermal; OXO Brew 12-Cup and 8-Cup Glass Carafe; Origami Air S; xBloom Studio. |
French presses are not in the count: their filter is a built-in mesh, and Orrje et al. list plungers among the brews that use a metal filter. For presses, best French presses is the page. The AeroPress steps, including where the filter goes, are in how to use an AeroPress.
What does a metal filter ask of you after the brew?
Paper is a pack you keep buying and bin; the filter-size guide counts filters a year from the pack you buy. Chemex states its paper is compostable and needs no basket to empty or clean. A metal filter is bought once, and what it asks of you is cleaning:
- AeroPress states its stainless filter is "easy to clean: just rinse and dry", goes on the top rack of the dishwasher, is "infinitely reuseable", and carries a 1-year warranty.
- Able states its Kone needs "a quick rinse and occasional scrub".
- Moccamaster states reusable filters "are difficult to clean properly", one reason it advises against them.
What about a cloth filter?
One study point only. Orrje et al. poured boiled coffee through a two-layer polyester/acrylic sock, "an occasional household recommendation as potential substitution for a paper filter", and measured 28.0 mg/L of cafestol against 939.2 mg/L unfiltered (one brew, mean of duplicate analyses). We cover no cloth filter product, so there is no pick here.
Moccamaster and Able disagree on a metal filter. Which should you believe?
Both are printed; neither is averaged. Moccamaster's manual advises against gold-mesh and other reusable filters. Able, a maker of metal filters, states its Kone "also fits Ratio Eight, Technivorm Moccamaster and Bonavita automatic drip brewers", and that its Basket fits "basket style coffee makers from Ratio, OXO, Breville, Cuisinart, Bonavita, and more", but not Fellow coffee makers. The Moccamaster maker is the one that answers for its own brewer, so check its manual before buying a metal filter for it. This page does not know what either choice does to a warranty.
Models this page mentions
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page.
Mentioned in: Paper vs metal coffee filter: which should you use?
- AeroPress Original Coffee MakerView on Amazon, AeroPress Original Coffee Maker (opens in a new tab)

Breville the Luxe Brewer Thermal
Frequently asked questions
Do paper coffee filters have chemicals?
What is a substitute for filter paper?
Sources
- The cholesterol-raising factor from coffee beans — Urgert and Katan, Annual Review of Nutrition 17 (1997), abstract (Europe PMC 9240930), accessed November 17, 2026
- Coffee consumption and serum lipids: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled clinical trials — Jee et al., American Journal of Epidemiology 153(4), 2001, abstract (Europe PMC 11207153), accessed November 17, 2026
- Cafestol and kahweol concentrations in workplace machine coffee compared with conventional brewing methods — Orrje et al., Nutrition, Metabolism and Cardiovascular Diseases, 2025 (open access, CC BY 4.0), accessed November 17, 2026
- AeroPress Stainless Steel Filter, Standard — AeroPress, accessed November 17, 2026
- Espresso Style Coffee with an AeroPress Metal Filter — AeroPress, accessed November 17, 2026
- AeroPress Flow Control Filter Cap — AeroPress, accessed November 17, 2026
- Filter series info and support — Chemex, accessed November 17, 2026
- Chemex Bonded Filters, Unfolded Circles (FP‑1) — Chemex, accessed November 17, 2026
- Ottomatic Quick Start card (QuickStart_Otto_2026) — Chemex, accessed November 17, 2026
- Kone, reusable filter for Chemex — Able Brewing, accessed November 17, 2026
- Basket, reusable filter for automatic coffee makers — Able Brewing, accessed November 17, 2026
- Moccamaster USA instruction manual v23.0 (all brewers) — Moccamaster USA (Technivorm), accessed November 17, 2026
- Luxe Brewer instruction book BDC415/BDC465 (US/Canada, 2025) — Breville, accessed November 17, 2026
- Ratio Six Coffee Machine (Series 2), US product page — Ratio, accessed November 17, 2026