Skip to content
Brew Method Guide

Independent · not affiliated with Amazon

Find your setup

Buying guide

Best Cold Brew Coffee Makers: Which Fits Your Batch and Fridge?

Assessment based on manufacturer documentation and independent published sources; we have not physically tested these products.

·

By Syed Hyder Ali · Updated · How we research

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page.

Our 4 picks

Key caveat

The Compact showed out of stock at OXO on 16 November 2026; Toddy's documents disagree on yield and height.

  1. For a week of concentrate, with a drain switch

    OXO Brew Cold Brew Coffee Maker (32 oz carafe)

    Capacity
    : 40 fl oz
    Steep time
    : 12 to 24 hours (or overnight)

    Why it fits: Fill once, then pour a glass most days

    List price $59.99 at OXO (Nov 16, 2026)

    Amazon listing not confirmed for this exact model · Maker's page (opens in a new tab)

    Our analysis
  2. For one or two drinkers and a lower shelf

    OXO Brew Compact Cold Brew Coffee Maker

    Capacity
    : 24 fl oz
    Steep time
    : 12-24 h counter, 20-24 h fridge Sources disagree

    Why it fits: Less to wash, and a shorter stand to fit

    List price $39.99 at OXO (Nov 16, 2026)

    Temporarily unavailable from the maker · Maker's page (opens in a new tab)

    Our analysis

Compare the picks

Values as the makers publish them; conditions in each model's spec sheet. Figures after "≈" are our unit conversions.

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page.

How we chose

  1. What one fill makes, by each maker's own recipe.

  2. How tall the stand or pitcher is, and who states the height.

  3. The filter it takes and what you replace.

  4. What goes in the dishwasher and what is washed by hand.

  5. Models sold new, with the Amazon listing state shown.

  6. Where sources disagree, both figures are shown, never averaged.

How we research

Our picks in detail

OXO Brew Cold Brew Coffee Maker (32 oz carafe) — For a week of concentrate, with a drain switch

Model 1272880 · stand with brew-release switch

OXO Brew Cold Brew Coffee Maker with 32 oz glass carafe
Best for
Someone who drinks cold brew most days, wants about a week of concentrate from one fill and has about 15 in of clear height.
Skip if
Your shelf is under 15 in, or you do not want to hand-wash a stand, a lid and a filter cap: only the glass carafe goes in the dishwasher.
Important limitation
Everything except the glass carafe is hand-wash only, and Wirecutter says the carafe can break.
Capacity
: 40 fl oz (≈ 1.18 L)
Steep time
: 12 to 24 hours (or overnight)
Filter
: Reusable ultra-fine stainless steel mesh filter
Makes
: Concentrate

List price $59.99 at OXO (Nov 16, 2026)

Amazon listing not confirmed for this exact model. Amazon listing not checked yet, so no button; OXO's US store had it in stock on 16 November 2026. Maker's page (opens in a new tab)

Our take

Pick it for a week of concentrate poured through a switch you can pause. Choose the Compact for one or two drinkers, or the Takeya for a short shelf; both stand lower.

OXO's recipe is 10 oz (284 g) of coarse coffee and up to 40 fl oz (1200 mL) of water. One fill makes 24-28 fl oz (700-800 mL) of concentrate, which at OXO's 2 fl oz of concentrate to 4-6 fl oz of water or milk is 12-14 drinks. The concentrate keeps up to two weeks in the fridge. Wirecutter's reviewers sometimes got closer to 33 fl oz from a fill.

The stand puts the whole brewer at 14.7 in (OXO's measurement; Wirecutter says about 15 in set up). That clears most kitchen cabinets, but it is tall for a fridge shelf: Home Grounds found it awkwardly tall and brewed on the counter instead. The pieces nest together for storage.

The mesh filter works alone. OXO sells paper filters as an option, but in Wirecutter's review they blocked the flow and the mesh alone gave the best results. Coarse grounds drain in about 20 minutes; a finer grind is far slower, up to 45 minutes to an hour for an espresso grind (OXO's booklet). Home Grounds says it can leak if over-tightened. OXO sells a replacement carafe and guarantees the brewer for replacement or refund.

Serious Eats, which did not pick it, said it had the most parts of the 8 makers it compared (pitcher, stand, lid, glass beaker, beaker lid), and that the separate stand and lids felt bulky and finicky.

Compared with the Compact: 24-28 fl oz of concentrate against 16, which is about 1.5 to 1.75 times the batch, and about 4 in taller. It is the only one of the four with a separate stand and a drain switch.

Strengths

  • Wirecutter's top pick: the strongest, boldest brew it tested, and the easiest to use
  • Switch-controlled drain that can be paused midway
  • Home Grounds' top pick: ultra-smooth coffee with more complexity than others

Limitations

  • Everything except the glass carafe is hand-wash only
  • Home Grounds: awkwardly tall when assembled, so the reviewer brewed on the counter rather than in the fridge

What matters: Fill once, then pour a glass most days

OXO Brew Compact Cold Brew Coffee Maker — For one or two drinkers and a lower shelf

Model 11237500 · borosilicate glass carafe with cork stopper

Capacity
: 24 fl oz (≈ 710 mL)
Steep time
: 12-24 h counter, 20-24 h fridge Sources disagree
Filter
: Reusable ultra-fine stainless steel mesh filter Sources disagree
Makes
: Concentrate
Best for
One or two drinkers who want a small batch, a stand about 4 in lower than the 32 oz, and fewer parts.
Skip if
You need it this week (OXO's US store showed it out of stock on 16 November 2026), or you want to add paper filters: OXO's manual and Wirecutter disagree.
Important limitation
A small batch: 16 fl oz of concentrate, 5-7 drinks. Hand-wash everything except the glass carafe.

List price $39.99 at OXO (Nov 16, 2026)

Temporarily unavailable from the maker (checked November 16, 2026). OXO's US store showed it out of stock on 16 November 2026, so there is no Amazon button; OXO names no replacement. Maker's page (opens in a new tab)

Our take

Pick it for one or two drinkers if you can buy it. If OXO has none, the Takeya is the other short-shelf pick; the OXO 32 oz makes about 1.5 to 1.75 times the concentrate.

OXO's recipe is 6 oz (175 g) of coarse coffee and 24 fl oz (700 mL) of water, making 16 fl oz of concentrate, which OXO puts at 5-7 drinks at 1 part concentrate to 2 or 3 parts water or milk. Wirecutter found its concentrate stronger and less balanced than the 32 oz's, so dilute it to taste.

Wirecutter puts it at 11 in tall assembled and says the carafe nests inside the reservoir for storage; OXO lists no height. A fill line marks the grounds, and the carafe's 12 fl oz dot lets you measure the water, so you need no jug. Wirecutter found it the simplest of its picks to use and clean, and Serious Eats made it its editor's pick for the same fill lines, saying one batch makes about seven cups of coffee.

One catch decides what you can stand it on: the drain opens only on a narrow-mouth vessel. Mason jars were too wide in Wirecutter's review and a standard-mouth Hydro Flask worked. If the carafe breaks, Wirecutter says a replacement costs almost as much as the brewer.

Compared with the OXO 32 oz: the same family and the same Rainmaker lid that spreads the water, about 4 in shorter, no separate stand, and 16 fl oz of concentrate against 24-28.

Strengths

  • Small footprint; brewer and carafe nest together
  • Wirecutter 'also great' pick: the simplest of its picks to use and clean
  • Serious Eats editor's pick: fill lines on container and carafe remove the need to measure

Limitations

  • Out of stock at OXO's US store on November 16, 2026
  • Small batch: about 16 oz of concentrate, 5-7 drinks

What matters: Less to wash, and a shorter stand to fit

Takeya Cold Brew Coffee Maker, 1 Quart — For one pitcher that brews, stores and serves

Model 10310 · Black, Tritan pitcher

Takeya Cold Brew Coffee Maker, 1 quart, Black
Best for
Someone with a short shelf who wants one pitcher to brew in, store in and pour from, and will work out their own dilution.
Skip if
You want a stated dilution, a sturdier filter or a maker Wirecutter likes: it found tall-basket pitchers like this one watery.
Important limitation
Takeya gives no dilution ratio, and Home Grounds found the filter flimsy.
Capacity
: 946 mL (≈ 32 fl oz)
Steep time
: 24 hours, refrigerated
Filter
: Ultra-fine mesh filter that holds the grounds inside the pitcher
Makes
: Cold brew to pour over ice

Our take

Pick it when shelf height is the problem: at 9.25 in it is the only one of the four under 10 in. Choose the Compact for a stronger concentrate in a small batch, or the Toddy for a cleaner cup.

Takeya's recipe is about 106 g (1¼ cups) of coarse coffee in the filter, the 946 mL (≈ 32 fl oz) pitcher filled with cold filtered water to ½ in from the top, a 30-second shake, then 24 hours in the fridge. Takeya says the result keeps up to two weeks and pours over ice, but it gives no dilution ratio, so how many drinks one fill makes depends on how you dilute it.

The pitcher is 9.25 in tall, 6.1 in wide and 4.1 in deep, and weighs 1.03 lb. Home Grounds reviewed Takeya's 32 oz Tritan model: it fit a fridge shelf, but its handle kept it out of the reviewer's fridge door (fridge designs vary).

Takeya calls it dishwasher safe but does not itemise the parts. It sells a replacement ultra-fine mesh filter. Reviewers disagree on the cup: Home Grounds found it balanced rather than complex, while Wirecutter lists Takeya's cold brew maker among tall-basket pitchers that were hard to set up, messy and watery (it does not say which version). Takeya also sells a 2 qt that is 12.2 in tall and 1.24 lb, which this page does not cover.

Strengths

  • Shatter-resistant, dishwasher-safe Tritan pitcher
  • Home Grounds found it under 10 inches tall and easy to fit on a fridge shelf
  • Takeya sells a replacement mesh filter for the 1 qt

Limitations

  • One-year warranty for makers, O-rings excluded, and only for buys from Takeya or its authorized US sellers
  • Wirecutter: brewers with a tall cylindrical basket, Takeya's included, were hard to set up, messy and made watery coffee

What matters: One vessel to wash, and it fits a short shelf

Toddy Home Cold Brew System — For the largest batch, through a felt filter

Model THM · Home Cold Brew System with glass decanter

Capacity
: 64 fl oz (≈ 1.89 L)
Steep time
: 8-24 h at room temperature
Filter
: Reusable polyester felt disc filter (two supplied), with optional single-use Toddy OS Paper Filter Bags
Makes
: Concentrate Sources disagree
Best for
Someone who drinks a lot of cold brew, wants a finer grind and a sediment-free cup, and will rinse a felt filter and keep it in the freezer between batches.
Skip if
You have a short shelf (Home Grounds found it too tall for its fridge), or you do not want filters that wear out after 10 uses or 3 months.
Important limitation
Takes only Toddy's own felt or paper-bag filters; standard paper filters do not fit.

Our take

Pick it for the largest batch and a sediment-free cup if you accept filters that wear out. Choose the OXO 32 oz for a switch and a mesh filter you do not replace, or the Takeya for a short shelf.

Toddy's recipe is 12 oz (340 g) of coarse coffee and 64 fl oz (1.9 L) of water, steeped 8-24 hours at room temperature, then drained into the glass decanter. Toddy's own documents give the yield as about 40 fl oz in its 2026 guide and 36-38 fl oz in its product-page FAQ, so expect somewhere in that range (details under the disagreements below).

The filter is the point. A felt disc sits in the bottom of the container, with an optional single-use paper bag. Home Grounds found the felt allowed a finer grind and a brew in as little as 8 hours, with a sediment-free cup. The felt is good for up to 10 uses or 3 months, is rinsed in water with no soap and goes into the freezer in a sealed bag. Stirring is not recommended with the felt alone, because it can clog and stall the drain.

Toddy does not say what height to plan for: its page lists 14.5 in and 11.75 in in two unlabelled blocks and the 2018 sheet 12.5 in. Home Grounds found it too tall for its fridge, so measure the shelf against the 14.5 in figure first. Wirecutter lists it among makers it did not pick: the white plastic bucket stains easily, it is more complicated to use and the coffee was less flavorful. Home Grounds names it a runner-up and calls it easy to set up, brew and clean. Serious Eats found the filtering gave smooth, silt-free coffee but only slightly better than the single steel filters of simpler makers, and called the system oversized and flimsy, with a plastic handle that bent under the weight of the coffee.

Strengths

  • Serious Eats found its felt and paper filtering gave smooth, silt-free coffee
  • Home Grounds brewed it in as little as 8 hours with a finer grind and a sediment-free cup
  • Toddy sells replacement filters, decanter, stopper, brewing container, lid and handle

Limitations

  • Needs Toddy's own felt or paper filters; standard paper filters do not fit
  • Felt filters wear out after 10 uses or 3 months and are stored in the freezer between batches

What matters: Feeds a heavy cold brew habit with a clean cup

How much does one fill make, and how tall does it stand?

Each recipe uses a different amount of coffee and water, so compare what a fill makes and what it stands next to. OXO and Takeya state their own heights, Wirecutter gives the Compact's, and Toddy's own pages disagree.

MakerCoffee and water per fillWhat one fill makesHeight assembled
OXO Brew 32 oz
10 oz (284 g) coffee; up to 40 fl oz (1200 mL) water
24-28 fl oz (700-800 mL) concentrate; 12-14 drinks
14.7 in (OXO); about 15 in (Wirecutter)
OXO Brew Compact
6 oz (175 g) coffee; 24 fl oz (700 mL) water
16 fl oz concentrate; 5-7 drinks
About 11 in (Wirecutter); OXO lists none
Takeya 1 qt
About 106 g (1¼ cups) coffee; the 946 mL pitcher filled
Not listed; pour over ice, no dilution given
9.25 in (Takeya)
Toddy Home
12 oz (340 g) coffee; 64 fl oz (1.9 L) water
40 fl oz (1.2 L) in the 2026 guide; 36-38 fl oz in the product FAQ
Not settled: 14.5, 11.75 and 12.5 in in three unlabelled blocks

To check a shelf, subtract: a shelf with 12 in of clear height takes the Compact (about 11 in) and the Takeya (9.25 in), and rules out the OXO 32 oz (14.7 in). The Toddy needs a tape measure against its own container and decanter.

A bigger fill is not a better brew: it is more concentrate to store and dilute. If you are unsure cold brew is the drink you want, cold brew or iced coffee sets the two side by side.

Mesh, paper or felt: which filter will you live with?

Three of the four use a reusable mesh that you rinse and keep: the OXO 32 oz (steel), the Compact (steel) and the Takeya (ultra-fine mesh inside the pitcher). The Toddy uses a felt disc that wears out. Home Grounds' general view is that paper gives the cleanest cup but is single-use, mesh is easy to clean but lets more sediment through, and cloth sits between the two and is the most tiresome to look after.

  • OXO 32 oz: mesh alone. OXO sells paper filters, but Wirecutter found they blocked the flow and got its best results from the mesh by itself.
  • OXO Compact: mesh. OXO's manual says OXO paper filters can add a second level; Wirecutter says the Compact does not include or work with paper.
  • Takeya: mesh. Home Grounds found the filter flimsy; Takeya sells a replacement.
  • Toddy: felt, with optional single-use paper bags. Home Grounds credits the felt with a sediment-free cup and a finer grind. Standard paper filters do not fit.

No source we read measures grit, so read "sediment-free" as a reviewer's description. All four want coarse grounds: what a coarse grind looks like. Per fill they take 284 g (OXO 32 oz), 175 g (Compact), about 106 g (Takeya) and 340 g (Toddy), so the biggest batch is also the most coffee to buy.

What do you wash by hand, and what do you replace?

  • OXO 32 oz: the glass carafe is dishwasher safe; hand-wash the stand, lid, container and filter cap. If you take out the gasket in the filter cap to clean it, refit it untwisted or it may leak. The carafe can break and OXO sells a replacement.
  • OXO Compact: the carafe goes in the dishwasher; hand-wash the rest. Twist off the container's bottom to clean it, then press the valve to release leftover water.
  • Takeya: Takeya calls the maker dishwasher safe and does not say which parts. The warranty is one year, excludes the silicone O-rings and covers only purchases from Takeya or an authorized US seller.
  • Toddy: dishwasher safe, but Toddy recommends hand-washing every reusable part. Rinse the felt in water only. Replace it after 10 uses or 3 months. Filters and other genuine parts are sold. The warranty is one year with proof of purchase from Toddy or an authorized reseller.

The washing-up differs: only the glass carafe of either OXO goes in the dishwasher, Takeya calls its whole maker dishwasher safe, and the Toddy adds a filter to rinse, freeze and replace. The care routine for any of them: cleaning coffee equipment.

Where do the makers' documents and the reviewers disagree?

Each figure is printed with its source and never averaged.

QuestionOne source saysAnother says
Toddy yield from 12 oz of coffee
About 40 fl oz (1.2 L): Toddy's 2026 guide
About 36-38 fl oz: Toddy's product-page FAQ. A 2018 spec sheet says up to 48 fl oz from one pound, a different recipe.
Toddy height
14.5 in ("Item") and 11.75 in ("Unit"): Toddy's product page, which does not say what each measures
12.5 in: Toddy's 2018 spec sheet
Toddy felt filter life
Up to 10 uses, discard after 3 months: Toddy
Replace after 12 uses or three months: Home Grounds, describing Toddy's advice
OXO 32 oz yield
24-28 fl oz from 10 oz of coffee: OXO's instructions
Sometimes closer to 33 fl oz: Wirecutter's reviewers
OXO Compact paper filters
Can be used for a second level of filtration: OXO's manual
Does not include or work with paper: Wirecutter
OXO Compact steep time
12-24 h on the counter, 20-24 h in the fridge: OXO's manual
12-24 h on the counter or in the fridge: OXO's product page
Takeya warranty
One year for pitchers and makers, O-rings excluded: Takeya's warranty page
A limited lifetime warranty on bottles and accessories: the product-page FAQ, and Takeya's warranty chart lists lifetime for its Tritan lines

The reviewers disagree about the makers too. The OXO 32 oz is Wirecutter's top pick and Home Grounds' top pick, but Serious Eats found it had the most parts of the eight it compared. The Compact is Serious Eats' editor's pick and one of Wirecutter's "also great" picks. The Toddy is a runner-up at Home Grounds and a maker neither Wirecutter nor Serious Eats picked. The Takeya is balanced rather than complex at Home Grounds and watery at Wirecutter, which does not say which version it tried. No single verdict settles the four.

Is a dedicated cold brew maker what you need?

Our four cover stand-and-switch, small-batch, pitcher and felt-filter designs. They do not cover every maker: Home Grounds ranks the Hario Mizudashi, a slim glass pitcher, as its best cold brew pitcher and says it fits a fridge door, which none of our four did in that review. Wirecutter found Hario's pot watery and messy, so the two disagree. Serious Eats' own winners are the KitchenAid 38 oz stainless maker and, as its best pitcher, the Ovalware. This page does not cover any of them, so if door fit is your constraint it cannot settle it.

  • You want to try cold brew first: a maker-credited cold brew method shows the steps with what you already own.
  • You own the Luxe Brewer Thermal from Breville: its instruction book lists a Cold Brew mode for up to 4 cups (600 mL, 20 fl oz) with a steep of 30 minutes to 36 hours. Its card is in best drip coffee makers.
  • You own an AeroPress: its maker says the AeroPress Original Coffee Maker can make cold brew style coffee. See the AeroPress Original review.
  • You have not yet chosen a method: manual brewers compares the options.

Models this page mentions

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page.

Which cold brew maker for which situation

  • You drink cold brew most days and have 15 in of height: the OXO Brew 32 oz, about 12-14 drinks a fill. Skip it if you will not hand-wash the parts; the Compact has fewer.
  • You are one or two drinkers: the OXO Brew Compact, 16 fl oz a fill, about 11 in tall. OXO's store showed it out of stock on 16 November 2026, so the alternative is the Takeya.
  • Your shelf is short: the Takeya, 9.25 in, one pitcher. You supply the dilution, and the filter feels flimsy to Home Grounds.
  • You want the biggest batch and a sediment-free cup: the Toddy, 64 fl oz of water per fill. Plan on replacing the felt every 10 uses, and measure the shelf first.

Sources

  1. Cold Brew Coffee Maker (SKU 1272880) product page — OXO, accessed November 16, 2026
  2. Cold Brew Coffee Maker instruction booklet (2014 edition, copy hosted by The Home Depot) — OXO, accessed November 17, 2026
  3. Compact Cold Brew Coffee Maker (SKU 11237500) product page — OXO, accessed November 16, 2026
  4. Compact Cold Brew Coffee Maker instruction manual (February 2020, copy hosted by Williams‑Sonoma) — OXO, accessed November 17, 2026
  5. Takeya Cold Brew Coffee Maker — Takeya USA, accessed November 17, 2026
  6. How to brew cold brew coffee (1 qt and 2 qt recipes) — Takeya USA, accessed November 17, 2026
  7. Takeya USA Corporation Limited Warranty — Takeya USA, accessed November 17, 2026
  8. Toddy Home Cold Brew System, Brewing Guide (2026) — Toddy, accessed November 17, 2026
  9. Toddy Cold Brew System specification sheet (2018) — Toddy, accessed November 17, 2026
  10. Toddy Cold Brew System product page and FAQ — Toddy, accessed November 17, 2026
  11. The Best Cold‑Brew Coffee Maker (updated July 14, 2025) — Wirecutter, accessed November 17, 2026
  12. To Find the Best Cold Brew Makers, I Tried 8 of Them and Made 65 Cups of Coffee (Madeline Muzzi, published May 6, 2025; read through the Internet Archive capture of September 2, 2025, because seriouseats.com refuses scripted reads) — Serious Eats, accessed November 17, 2026
  13. The Best Cold Brew Coffee Maker (Julia Bobak, updated February 28, 2026) — Home Grounds, accessed November 17, 2026
  14. Luxe Brewer Thermal instruction book (BDC415/BDC465) — Breville, accessed November 17, 2026
  15. AeroPress Original Coffee Maker — AeroPress, accessed November 17, 2026
  16. Coffee Makers & Grinders category page, US (read in a headless browser) — OXO, accessed November 16, 2026
  17. Cold Brew Coffee Maker instruction manual, Use & Care (OXO amfile download; read through Exa's copy of that URL) — OXO, accessed November 17, 2026
  18. Cold Brew Coffee Maker instruction booklet (OXO, 2014 edition; copy hosted by The Home Depot), PDF page 9: Use & Care; To Store — OXO, accessed November 17, 2026
  19. Compact Cold Brew Coffee Maker instruction manual (OXO document dated February 2020; copy hosted by Williams‑Sonoma), PDF page 3: Cold Brew Concentrate Recipe; cleaning and storage notes — OXO, accessed November 17, 2026
  20. Ultra Fine Mesh Coffee Filter (1 qt 81078-T, 2 qt 81079-T), US product feed — Takeya USA, accessed November 16, 2026
  21. Pitcher Lid & Handle (SKU 97010), US product feed — Takeya USA, accessed November 16, 2026
  22. Pitcher Lid O‑Ring 2 Pack (SKU 81025), US product feed — Takeya USA, accessed November 16, 2026
  23. Toddy Cold Brew System Filters & Parts — Toddy, accessed November 16, 2026
  24. Toddy Home Cold Brew System Brewing Guide (version 8-2026), PDF page 9: Frequently Asked Questions (filter life) — Toddy, accessed November 17, 2026
  25. Toddy Home Cold Brew System Brewing Guide (version 8-2026), PDF page 8: Easy Cleanup — Toddy, accessed November 17, 2026
  26. Toddy Home Cold Brew System Brewing Guide (version 8-2026), PDF page 2: Parts; Wash before use — Toddy, accessed November 17, 2026
  27. Toddy Home Cold Brew System Brewing Guide (version 8-2026), PDF page 10: Frequently Asked Questions (longtime use) — Toddy, accessed November 17, 2026