Skip to content
Brew Method Guide

Independent · not affiliated with Amazon

Find your setup

Tools and guides

Cold brew vs iced coffee: which to make, and what the button on your machine means

How each is made, how much coffee reaches the glass, and what a machine's cold brew setting really does.

Assessment based on manufacturer documentation and independent published sources; we have not physically tested these products.

By Syed Hyder Ali · Updated · How we research

In short

Cold brew vs iced coffee comes down to how the coffee is brewed: cold brew is steeped in cool water for hours, iced coffee is brewed hot and chilled. Make cold brew if you want a batch in the fridge; make iced coffee for one glass now. A machine's "cold brew" button can mean a 36-hour steep or a 3-minute brew.

Worked example

Coffee
10 oz (284 g) coarse grounds, OXO Brew Cold Brew
Concentrate
24 to 28 fl oz per batch
One drink
2 fl oz concentrate, 4-6 fl oz water or milk

284 g ÷ 24 to 28 fl oz = 10.1 to 11.8 g per fl oz of concentrate. × 2 fl oz = 20.3 to 23.7 g in a drink of 6 to 8 fl oz.

2.5 to 3.9 g of coffee per fl oz of drink

Pour more concentrate or dilute less and the figure rises; add ice and it falls, as OXO's booklet notes. An iced coffee has no figure on this basis: Starbucks's flash brew uses about 4 g per fl oz of hot water, and the ice that melts into it is not counted.

Assumptions and exclusions

This assumes

  • OXO's recipe, from its 2014 instruction booklet
  • Strength means coffee per fl oz of drink
  • Starbucks's two published iced coffee methods

This does not cover

  • Caffeine, acidity and health claims
  • Recipes of our own
  • Iced lattes and other milk drinks

Which should you make, cold brew or iced coffee?

The two differ in how the coffee is brewed, and that decides your schedule. The National Coffee Association (NCA) says cold brew is traditionally "coffee made using room-temperature or cooler water", and iced coffee is "coffee that has been brewed hot using a standard method, then cooled down to serve". Starbucks puts cold brew's steep at "usually anywhere from 12–24 hours".

Which to make, by how you drink cold coffee
If youMakeBecauseIt needs
Drink cold coffee most days and want a glass ready
Cold brew
One steep keeps up to two weeks refrigerated (OXO, Toddy and Takeya state it), so it covers many glasses. Choose iced coffee instead if you will not plan a day ahead.
A coarse grind, fridge space, a reusable mesh or felt filter, and 12 to 24 hours. For brewers, see cold brew coffee makers.
Want one glass now
Iced coffee
It is brewed hot, so it takes the time of a hot brew: about 5 minutes for drip (NCA). Choose cold brew instead if you want the same glass every day without brewing each time.
A hot brewer and ice. Starbucks's flash brew guide uses a Chemex pour-over: see pour-over coffee equipment.
Want milk in it
Either
OXO suggests 2 fl oz of cold brew concentrate with 4 to 6 fl oz of water or milk; Toddy starts at 1 part concentrate to 2 parts water or milk.
Nothing extra.
Drink one cold coffee a week
Iced coffee
There is no batch to finish. Choose cold brew instead only if you will drink the concentrate within its two weeks.
Nothing extra.
Have no coarse grinder
Iced coffee
Cold brew calls for a coarse grind: NCA says to "start with a coarse grind", and OXO says an espresso grind can take 45 to 60 minutes to drain.
A grinder with a coarse setting; see the grind size chart.

How is each one made, and what does that change?

Cold brew and iced coffee, as NCA, Starbucks and the cold brew makers state them
Cold brewIced coffee
Water
Room-temperature or cooler (NCA); "cool filtered water" (Starbucks).
Hot, then chilled (NCA).
Time
"From as little as a few minutes to 12–18+ hours", about 12 typical (NCA); "usually anywhere from 12–24 hours" (Starbucks). OXO, Toddy and Takeya say 12 to 24 hours, 8 to 24 hours and 24 hours.
About 5 minutes for a drip brew (NCA).
What you pour
A concentrate you dilute: 1 part to 2 or 3 parts water or milk (OXO), starting at 1 to 2 (Toddy). Takeya lists no dilution ratio.
Starbucks's two published methods: coffee brewed at double strength, "4 tablespoons of coffee for every 6 fluid ounces", poured over ice; or flash brewing, coffee "brewed directly onto ice".
Keeps
Up to two weeks refrigerated (OXO, Toddy, Takeya).
Not listed by either Starbucks page.
Filter
A reusable mesh filter (OXO, Takeya) or felt filter (Toddy).
Whatever your hot brewer takes.

Starbucks describes the taste and body differently: cold brew has "a natural sweetness with a hint of chocolaty flavor", is "naturally full-bodied" and has "lower acidity"; iced coffee is "lighter, with a medium body" with "caramel and cola notes". NCA calls cold brew's taste "less bitter" and "smoother". These are the sources' own descriptions of taste.

Two sources differ on how short a steep can be. NCA allows "as little as a few minutes"; Starbucks says usually 12 to 24 hours. That difference explains the machine table below. Starbucks's flash brew guide also prints two tablespoon counts for the same 40 g of coffee (8 and 3), so grams are used here. For the steps themselves, see how to make cold brew.

Which puts more coffee in the glass?

Here, strength means grams of coffee per fl oz of drink, not caffeine. At the makers' own dilutions, cold brew drinks hold 2.5 to 3.9 g of coffee per fl oz. Iced coffee depends on how much ice melts into it, which neither Starbucks page states, so it cannot go on the same line. Within OXO's own recipe, pouring 1 to 2 instead of 1 to 3 raises the figure by about a third, and the 24 to 28 fl oz range of concentrate yield moves it by about a sixth.

Coffee per fl oz of drink, from the makers' own recipes (our arithmetic)
RecipeMaker's figuresCoffee per fl ozBasis
OXO Brew Cold Brew 32 oz
284 g in 24 to 28 fl oz of concentrate; 2 fl oz with 4 to 6 fl oz of water or milk
2.5 to 3.9 g
Finished drink, 1:3 to 1:2
Toddy Home Cold Brew System
340 g, about 40 fl oz of concentrate (2026 guide); 1 part with 2 parts water or milk
2.8 g
Finished drink at 1:2
Starbucks flash brew
40 g of coffee in 300 mL (about 10 fl oz) of hot water, brewed onto 1¼ cups of ice
3.9 g
Per fl oz of hot water; the ice that melts in is not counted, so this is not a finished-drink figure
Starbucks double strength
4 tablespoons per 6 fl oz of water, poured over ice
Not computed
Tablespoons are not grams, and the ice is not stated
How it is calculated

OXO: 284 g ÷ 28 fl oz = 10.1 g per fl oz of concentrate and 284 g ÷ 24 fl oz = 11.8 g. A 2 fl oz pour is 20.3 to 23.7 g. In a drink of 2 + 6 = 8 fl oz that is 20.3 ÷ 8 = 2.5 g per fl oz; in 2 + 4 = 6 fl oz it is 23.7 ÷ 6 = 3.9 g. Toddy: 340 g ÷ 40 fl oz = 8.5 g per fl oz of concentrate, one part in three parts of drink = 2.8 g per fl oz. Toddy's page FAQ gives 36 to 38 fl oz for the same 12 oz of coffee, which would make it 3.0 to 3.1 g. Starbucks: 40 g ÷ 300 mL × 29.57 mL per fl oz = 3.9 g per fl oz of hot water. Takeya lists no dilution ratio, so no per-drink figure is computed for it.

For ratios beyond these recipes, and for weighing a dose, see the coffee-to-water ratio guide.

What does "cold brew" or "iced" mean on a machine?

What each machine's cold or iced setting does, from the makers, with what it means for cold brew
MachineThe settingWhat its maker statesWhat it means for cold brew
Breville Luxe Brewer Thermal
Cold Brew preset
Cold brew is selectable from 30 minutes to 36 hours.
You choose the steep time.
Fellow Aiden
Cold brew profile
A cold brew profile with a hot bloom; the batch basket takes up to 110 g for cold brew, against 82.5 g for standard brewing.
The hot bloom means not every step uses cool water.
Chemex Ottomatic 2.0
Switch position II, "iced coffee mode"
Position II brews with the warming plate off.
Named for iced coffee, not cold brew; no steep time is listed.
Ninja Luxe Café Premier
Drip "over ice" and Cold Brew
Drip coffee (classic, rich, over ice) and cold brew in sizes from 6 to 18 fl oz; the cold brew time is not listed.
Over ice is a drip setting; the cold brew steep time is unknown.
Breville Barista Touch Impress
Cold Brew preset
Cold brew in under 3 minutes (maker claim).
A minutes-long brew, at the short end of NCA's range and far from Starbucks's 12 to 24 hours.
Breville Oracle Jet
Cold Brew preset
Cold brew extracted in under 3 minutes (maker claim). Wirecutter (updated March 17, 2026) reports the setting gave lukewarm coffee, about 95°F.
A minutes-long brew, and one independent test found it lukewarm.
Nespresso Vertuo Pop+
Sizes "hot or over ice"; Coffee Creations
Five sizes from Espresso (1.35 fl oz) to XL (12 fl oz), hot or over ice; Coffee Creations brews a concentrated cup for recipes with milk or ice.
No cold brew setting is listed.

The same two words mean a steep of up to 36 hours on one machine and a brew of under 3 minutes on another, so read the maker's time before you buy for "cold brew". The Chemex's position II is called "iced coffee mode" and the Ninja has a separate drip "over ice" setting: both are named for iced coffee, not cold brew. If you want an hours-long steep from a machine, the Luxe Brewer is the one here whose manual gives hours; the others give minutes or no time.

What else do you need?

  • A coarse grinder. OXO says coarse grounds drain in about 20 minutes, while an espresso grind may take as long as 45 minutes to an hour. For how coarse "coarse" is, see the grind size chart.
  • Fridge space. Takeya's 1 qt pitcher steeps for 24 hours in the fridge and is 9.25 in high. OXO's 32 oz maker lists 9.5 x 9.5 x 14.7 in with the axes unlabelled, so 14.7 in is its largest dimension, not a confirmed height.
  • The right filters. Toddy needs its own felt filters or paper bags; standard paper filters do not fit.
  • Hand-washing. Everything on OXO's maker except the glass carafe is hand-wash only.

Models this page mentions

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page.

Sources

  1. Cold Brew Coffee — National Coffee Association (About Coffee), accessed November 17, 2026
  2. Drip Coffee — National Coffee Association (About Coffee), accessed November 17, 2026
  3. Cold Brew Versus Iced Coffee — Starbucks at Home, accessed November 17, 2026
  4. How to Flash Brew — Starbucks at Home, accessed November 17, 2026
  5. Cold Brew Coffee Maker instruction booklet (2014 edition, copy hosted by The Home Depot) — OXO, accessed November 17, 2026
  6. Home Cold Brew System Brewing Guide (version 8-2026) — Toddy, accessed November 17, 2026
  7. How To Cold Brew Coffee (posted May 27, 2025) — Takeya USA, accessed November 16, 2026
  8. Luxe Brewer instruction book BDC415/BDC465 (US/Canada, 2025) — Breville, accessed November 16, 2026
  9. Aiden Precision Coffee Maker, US product page — Fellow, accessed November 16, 2026
  10. Aiden: get-to-know-you guide (US) — Fellow, accessed November 16, 2026
  11. Ottomatic resources page — Chemex, accessed November 16, 2026
  12. SharkNinja Introduces Ninja Luxe Café: The Only 3-in-1 Espresso, Drip Coffee and Cold Brew Maker — SharkNinja, accessed November 16, 2026
  13. The Bambino-class Barista Touch Impress BES881 product page — Breville, accessed November 16, 2026
  14. The Oracle Jet BES985 product page — Breville, accessed November 16, 2026
  15. The Best Home Espresso Machine (updated March 17, 2026) — Wirecutter (The New York Times), accessed November 16, 2026
  16. Vertuo Pop+ Beige, US product page — Nespresso, accessed November 16, 2026